EB-1A · EB-2 NIW · O-1A petition preparationClients across 4 continentsWorking across U.S. & India time zones
Free profile evaluation →
Skip to content

EB-2 NIW Reference Letter Collection Form

SUBSTANTIAL MERITNATIONAL IMPORTANCEWELL POSITIONEDWAIVER BENEFIT

Purpose

This form helps you provide a recommendation letter for an individual applying for U.S. permanent residency under the EB-2 NIW (National Interest Waiver) category. Your letter must address three specific legal prongs established by the Matter of Dhanasar framework.

⚖️ The Three Dhanasar Prongs

Every section in this form maps to one or more of these:

Prong 1:The applicant's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance.
Prong 2:The applicant is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor.
Prong 3:On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the job offer and labor certification requirements.
ⓘ GUIDELINE ON METRICS & NUMBERS

If you are unsure of a specific number, describe the outcome qualitatively rather than estimating. It is better to say 'significantly improved outcomes' than to guess at a figure you cannot verify.

HOW TO COMPLETE THIS FORM
Complete all sections where you have direct knowledge
Use specific examples, dates, and measurable outcomes
Write 'N/A' for questions that do not apply to your experience
Avoid vague praise — focus on concrete impact and outcomes
More specific = stronger letter

What Makes a Strong NIW Letter

Connects the applicant's work to broader national benefit
Explains why results matter, not just what was done
Demonstrates urgency — why the U.S. needs this person's work now
Speaks to the applicant's unique position to advance their work

PROFESSIONAL DOCUMENTATION

EB-2 NIW Reference Letter Collection Form

Please provide detailed responses below. Your inputs will be used to generate the formal reference documentation. All changes are saved automatically to your local device.

Full legal name of the person you are recommending
Your full legal/professional name
Briefly describe what the applicant does and in what domain (e.g., 'AI-driven drug discovery for rare diseases')

Section I: Referee Credentials & Authority

Establishing your qualifications to evaluate the applicant

🏛️ Foundational — All Prongs: USCIS must trust your opinion. Before they value what you say about the applicant, they need to know why your opinion matters in this specific field.
Countries where you have worked
Example: Fellow of IEEE; Former Director at [Company]; Published 50+ papers; Recipient of [Award].
Explain your expertise and your position that enables you to assess the applicant's contributions and their significance to the field and the United States. Be specific about what you know that others might not.

Contact Information

Section II: Relationship & Professional Familiarity

How and how deeply you know the applicant's work

🔍 Foundational — Credibility of Testimony: Independent letters (from people who know the work but not the applicant personally) carry more weight. If you have worked together, you must clearly contextualize that relationship.
I directly supervised the applicant in a research, industry, or academic setting
I served as the applicant's mentor, thesis advisor, or dissertation committee member
I collaborated with the applicant on a specific project, research program, or publication
I am a peer in the same field at a different organization and know the applicant through our overlapping professional circles
I know the applicant through conferences, workshops, or professional associations
I reviewed or peer-reviewed the applicant's published work, grant proposals, or technical submissions
I am an independent expert with no prior working relationship — I know the applicant's work through its impact in the field
Other (describe below)
Provide context: conference, referral, joint project, journal publication, speaking event, grant committee, etc.
Describe the frequency, depth, and nature of your observation (e.g., weekly project meetings, reading their papers, attending their talks, reviewing their technical outputs, etc.)
Very familiar — I have direct, detailed, first-hand knowledge of their work and its impact
Familiar — I'm aware of their major contributions and have interacted with their work meaningfully
Somewhat familiar — I know their work generally through reputation and publications but have limited direct interaction
I am not related to the applicant by blood or marriage
I am not currently employed by the same organization as the applicant
I have no financial interest in the applicant's success (e.g., I am not an investor, business partner with financial stake, or paid promoter)
My statements are based on professional knowledge and direct observation of the applicant's work

Section III: Substantial Merit of the Applicant's Work

Prong 1A — Dhanasar Framework

⚖️ Prong 1A — Substantial Merit: The endeavor itself must be important in areas like business, science, technology, health, or education. Concrete, observable impact is required.
Be as specific as possible. What existed before, and what does the applicant's work change or improve?
Compare to other work in the area. Is this incremental progress or a meaningful advance? How would you characterize its importance to other experts?
Describe what is genuinely new or original — novel techniques, frameworks, algorithms, approaches, clinical protocols, policy frameworks, artistic methods, business models, etc.
This can include: improved outcomes, cost savings, efficiency gains, policy changes, product adoption, clinical implementation, adoption by practitioners, etc. Describe what you have directly observed or verified.

Evidence of external adoption is powerful proof of merit...

Yes — extensively (describe below)
Yes — to some degree (describe below)
Not to my knowledge
N/A

Section IV: National Importance of the Proposed Endeavor

Prong 1B — Dhanasar Framework

⚖️ Prong 1B — National Importance: The work must have potential prospective impact of national scale. It must extend beyond benefiting merely the employer or clients.
Think about: healthcare outcomes, economic impact, U.S. competitiveness in a strategic sector, public policy, national security, energy, environment, education, infrastructure, etc.
Examples: NIH funding priorities, DARPA programs, NSF priority areas, Department of Energy programs, White House science initiatives, executive orders, congressional mandates, or agency strategic plans.
What would be lost? Would another country gain a competitive or strategic advantage? Would patients, communities, or industries be negatively affected?

NIW requires impact beyond immediate employment...

Yes — clearly extends beyond one employer (describe below)
Somewhat — growing toward broader impact (describe below)
Not to my knowledge

Section V: Applicant is Well Positioned to Advance the Endeavor

Prong 2 — Dhanasar Framework

⚖️ Prong 2 — Well Positioned: The applicant must have the track record, network, and expertise to actually succeed in the proposed endeavor.
Be as specific as possible — rare technical skills, unique combinations of expertise, domain knowledge that few others have, etc.
Describe past accomplishments — publications, deployed products, patents, clinical outcomes, projects completed, problems solved. What is their track record?
Collaborators, grant funding, industry partnerships, access to data, laboratory resources, advisory relationships, etc.

Be direct. Is the applicant ahead of, at the level of, or behind their peers?...

Significantly ahead of peers at a similar stage (describe)
Ahead of most peers at a similar stage (describe)
At the level of strong peers — which is still impressive for NIW purposes (describe)
Hard to assess (explain why)
This helps USCIS understand the ongoing benefit, not just past accomplishment.

Section VI: Benefit of Waiving the Job Offer Requirement

Prong 3 — Dhanasar Framework

⚖️ Prong 3 — Benefit to Waive: On balance, it must be beneficial to the U.S. to waive the standard job offer and labor certification process (PERM).

Think about: research freedom, the need to collaborate across institutions...

Yes — their work clearly benefits from this flexibility
Somewhat
Not especially
N/A / I am not familiar with their employment situation
This can include: no qualified U.S. workers in this niche, the work has national benefits that shouldn't wait for bureaucratic timelines, their contributions already demonstrate no displacement of U.S. workers, etc.
Make the case directly: What does the U.S. gain? What is the cost of losing this person to another country or to the delays of conventional immigration processing?

Section VII: Publications, Citations & Scholarly Contributions

Evidence of recognized expertise and knowledge creation

📚 Primarily Prong 2 — Well Positioned (also supports Prong 1): Record of knowledge creation and evaluation of peers.
Yes — I have read or reviewed their publications
Yes — I am aware of their publications but have not read them in detail
No
Exceptional — their work is very widely cited relative to the field
Strong — meaningful citation record, especially given career stage
Solid — cited by relevant peers, consistent with strong researchers
Not enough information to assess
N/A — this is not a publication-oriented field

Reviewing for journals, reviewing grant proposals, sitting on conference program committees...

Yes (describe below)
No
N/A / Not aware

Section VIII: Recognition, Awards & Professional Standing

Evidence that the field recognizes the applicant's exceptional contributions

🏆 Primarily Prong 2 — Well Positioned (supports Prongs 1 & 3):
Yes (describe below)
Not to my knowledge
Yes (describe below)
Not to my knowledge
Yes (describe below)
Not to my knowledge
Yes (describe below)
Not to my knowledge

Section IX: Comparative Standing in the Field

Contextualizing the applicant's position among peers nationally and internationally

⚖️ Prong 2 — Well Positioned & Prong 3 — Benefit of Waiver:
Top 1% internationally in their specific area
Top 5% internationally in their specific area
Top 10% internationally in their specific area
Among the top professionals I have directly worked with or evaluated
Among the best, but difficult to estimate a precise percentile
How many professionals work in this area? Based on what specific evidence? What distinguishes the applicant from others at their level?
Yes — actively recognized and consulted
Yes — recognized in academic/research circles
Growing recognition
Unsure
Primarily national (recognized within the United States)
International (recognized across multiple countries)
Both — with strong national and international reach

Section X: Final Assessment & Overall Recommendation

Your professional judgment on the applicant's NIW eligibility

✍️ All Three Prongs — Synthesizing Your Assessment:
This is your opportunity to add any context not captured in earlier sections — extraordinary circumstances, unique mentorship, personal integrity, resilience, unusual contributions, etc.
Yes, absolutely — I have high confidence in their continued trajectory (describe)
Yes, likely — based on their track record (describe)
Uncertain (explain)
Reference their career stage, trajectory, and ongoing work.

The NIW standard asks: Does this person's work have substantial merit and national importance?...

Yes, strongly — I am highly confident this individual merits a National Interest Waiver
Yes — in my professional opinion, the NIW standard is met
Likely, but with some caveats (explain)
Uncertain (explain)
Please write a clear, direct concluding statement. This is the most important paragraph of your letter — it will be the last thing the adjudicator reads. Tie together the three prongs: merit, your confidence in the applicant, and the benefit to the U.S. of retaining them.
Progress saved locally

Download Your Reference Collection Document

Enter your email to download a Word document (.docx) containing all your responses — formatted and ready to share with your referee for review.

Your email will be added to our newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.